Earthquake and Tsunami

Reports of consultants

Duty Travel Report to Maldives - Dr. Vijay Chandra and Dr. Rajesh Pandav - Feb 24, 2005 - March 11, 2005

 

 PDF version

DUTY TRAVEL REPORT TO MALDIVES

Dr. Vijay Chandra and Dr. Rajesh Pandav

(Feb 24, 2005March 11, 2005)

 

Terms of reference

1.      Working with MOH, WR office and UNFPA develop and test an instrument for needs assessment of psychosocial distress in the community.

2.      Training of physicians to enhance their capacity in delivering mental health needs of the Tsunami affected community.

3.      Identify future country needs in developing their mental health system in short and long-term.

4.      Capacity building within the country in community mental health through training of community health workers in identification and management of epilepsy using SEARO modules.

 

Magnitude of the Tsunami disaster

The Tsunami resulted in massive damage to Maldives. Official government statistics report the following:

*      Displaced and homeless persons on 26 December:15,000

*      Islands totally evacuated : 13

*      Injured: 1,313

*      Deaths: 82

*      Missing: 26

 

The Maldives Government has said about 100,000 people i.e., more than one third of the total population has been affected. 15,000 have been displaced. A high number has been rendered unemployed or underemployed. There is substantial evidence that loss of employment and livelihood, particularly sudden loss, very frequently gives rise to anxiety and depressive disorders. Of the affected population about 30 to 50% of the population will need some form of psychosocial support ant 5 to 10% may need psychiatric care.

 

Psychosocial support activities in the community

The government of Maldives launched a well organized community-based campaign to provide psychosocial support to the disaster-affected persons. A Psychosocial Unit was formed in the National Disaster Management Centre. Immediately after the disaster, this unit mobilized volunteer groups consisting of some previously trained counselors working with different agencies and other volunteers interested in providing psychosocial support to the disaster affected community. All members of the team were local Maldivians who spoke the local language and were familiar with the local culture. Volunteers who were not trained in counseling were trained in a two day programme organized by Red Cross utilizing two experts from India, many such courses have been conducted and more are planned for the future. The volunteer teams immediately went to the islands and formed Emotional Support Brigades consisting of youth, elderly and health care providers. Through this out-reach programme, all affected islands have been reached, and each and every affected person has been provided at least some emotional and psychological support.

The above programme is being implemented by the Psychosocial Unit of the National Disaster Management Centre facilitated by UNFPA and UNICEF in terms of budget for travel and by Red Cross for training. WHO has also provided the technical material for training.

UNFPA has been officially designated as the coordinator of the psychosocial relief effort to the Tsunami affected community. 

Red Cross conducted a qualitative rapid assessment of the affected islands in terms of overall emotional status. However, a quantitative needs assessment of the magnitude of the psychosocial distress has not been carried out. WHO has been requested to assist the Government in developing the needed instruments to conduct this assessment. Red Cross also has long term plans for empowering communities for disaster preparedness for the future and developing income generation schemes.

 


Activities Undertaken

1.     Meetings held

a)      Discussions with Ms. Aminath Zeeniya, Programme Manager Mental health, Ministry of Health (MOH).

b)      Discussions with Dr. Manuel Carballo, Executive Director, International Centre for Migration and Health and consultant to UNFPA.

c)      Discussion with Dr. Satyabrata Das, Acting Country Manager, American Red Cross.

d)      Discussion with Mr. Abdul Hameed Coordinator, Psychosocial unit, Disaster Management Centre

e)      Attended consultation workshop for discussion of UNFPA Tsunami Emergency Projects on Reproductive and Psychosocial Support.

f)       Discussion with Dr. Abdul Azeez Yoosuf, Director General Health Services and Dr. Sheena Moosa, Deputy Director Health Services.

g)      Discussions with Dr. Sheena Moosa, Deputy Director Health Services and  Dr. Shehenaz Fahmy, Deputy Director, MOH.

h)      Discussion with staff at Faculty of Health Sciences, Ms.Aishath Ahment Didi, Assistant Lecturer and Curriculum Coordinator, Ms. Aishath Rameela, Assistant Lecturer and Ms. Mariyam Warujina, Assistant Lecturer.

 

2.     Development and testing of a needs assessment instrument for psychosocial distress in the community

The General Health Questionnaire (GHQ-12) has been extensively used in many countries as a measure of psychosocial distress. Starting with an original English version, it was translated into Dhivehi and back translated into English. It was then tested on a sample of 43 people affected by the Tsunami in one island. Analysis of the data suggested that those with a GHQ-12 score of 7 or more need additional psychosocial support. The five additional questions in the needs assessment questionnaire were also helpful to identify some more affected persons in need of psychosocial support.  A detailed report of the development and testing has been prepared (Annex 1)

 

 

3.     Training of physicians to enhance their capacity in delivering mental health needs of the Tsunami-affected community

Technical material prepared by SEARO for training of physicians, including power point slides to be used during training were handed over to the MOH. Unfortunately actual training of physicians could not be organized because of problems in transporting large number of physicians to Male. MOH is considering using a consultant in the future to conduct the training in Regional and Atoll hospitals.

However, since all physicians in the islands are expatriates (except one Maldivian), MOH was not keen to devote too much effort into training these physicians.

The same training material developed for physicians could be used in training community health workers and nurses who live in the islands and work there on a long-term basis. When needed these para-medical staff could be supported by doctors

 

4.     Identify future country needs in developing their mental health system in the short and long-term

The government of Maldives has expressed an interest in developing their mental health system which is suitable to its culture and its unique geographical layout.

a)     Strengthening the Ministry of Health

Development of National Mental Health Policy and Plan

1)      Workshop of stakeholders to be conducted to discuss the results of the mental health survey and development of mental health policy, plan and programme. WHO manual on assessment of mental health services and development of mental health policy, plans and programmes has been  provided to MOH.

2)      Recruitment of a mental health professional (to be based in MOH) to assist MOH in framing a mental health policy and plan. Attached draft TOR was discussed with MOH (Annex 2)

3)      Recruitment of a mental health consultant (to be based in WR office) for training of physicians, nurses, community health workers in mental health. Attached draft TOR was discussed with MOH (Annex 2)

 


b)     Developing mental heath services inIGMH, Male

Recommendations made by previous WHO consultants were discussed with MOH. MOH pointed out that there are two psychiatrists at IGMH, one of whom is a Maldivian. No other Maldivian psychiatrist is likely to be available in the near future. None of the existing Maldivian doctors in Male have expressed any interest in mental health. Thus the only possibility of enhancing mental health services at IGMH is by training of some nurses in psychiatric nursing. At present the cadre of psychiatric social worker and occupational therapist (recommended by the previous consultants) do not exist in Maldives, but could be considered in the long-term.

c)      Community mental health training at the RegionalHospital, AtollHospital and all smaller islands

Physicians at Regional and AtollHospitals, and island health centres are expatriate physicians, so MOH is not keen to devote too much resources on training them. Perhaps a video-based training programme could be considered. However, the practical solution is to train nurses and community health workers in mental health at the Regional, Atoll and all islands who will be available for service delivery on a long-term basis. This is particularly important as they are familiar with the local culture, and the only way for expatriate physicians to communicate with patients is through these local workers.

d)     School mental health programme

WHO technical material for teachers and parents on identification and management of behavioral and learning disorders is ready. The consultant who prepared this material can be sent for one week to train master trainers.

Director General Health Services said that this has to be discussed with the Ministry of Education to finalize the dates (probably later in the year)  for the training programme considering that multiple training programmes have already been undertaken and planned for Tsunami-related work.

e)     Undergraduate training in clinical psychology

MOH desires to send one student for training in a bachelor’s course in clinical psychology. This person will be placed in the Ministry of Health and will oversee clinical services, be responsible for supervision, management and training of paramedical workers. The person will be based in Male but will be required to travel to the Regions. Training of the identified candidate will be overseas at an appropriate Centre.

f)      Mental Health activities in other Ministries

Strengthening the Faculty of Health Sciences (FHS)

The faculty of health science is under the Ministry of Education. Discussions were held with FHS regarding a course in psychiatric nursing and inclusion of mental health training for community health workers. Based on these discussions the staff at the FHS need to observe similar courses being conducted overseas. The consultant in mental health who will be recruited for three months could also assist in developing a curriculum to be used for this training. The technical material developed by WHO for training of community health workers in the identification and management of generalized tonic clonic seizures can be included in the current curriculum.

Enhancing the management and staff capacity for Guraidhoo special care facility

The Home for Special Needs is an excellent facility for long-term care for people with special needs. The staff could benefit from updating their knowledge and skills in mental health.  The consultant in mental health to be recruited could assist the Ministry of Gender in this activity.

 

5.     Capacity building within the country in community mental health through training of community health workers in identification and management of epilepsy  using SEARO modules

Training for community health workers (as master trainers) in the identification and management of generalized tonic clonic seizures was conducted in the northern and southern region. In the northern region the training was conducted at the Kulhudufushi Regional Hosptila, Ha Dha Atoll. The training was attended by 15 participants ( 7 nurses from KulhudufushiRegionalHospital and 3 from the Shaviani and Haa Alif Atoll and 5 community health workers from the Shaviani and Haa Alif Atolls). In the southern region training was conducted at HithadhooRegionalHospital. The training was attended by 20 participants (13 Nurses, 2 Regional Health Officers and 6 Community Health Supervisors) from HithadhooRegionalHospitalHulhumedhoo Health Centre, Feydhoo Health Centre, Hulhudhoo Health Centre, Maradhoo Feydhoo Health Post,  and Gn.FurahmulahAtollHospital. The training was well received by the participants. Data collection, reporting and monitoring forms were also provided. (Annex 3).

 


6.     Recommendations

a)     Recommendations for psychosocial support to those identified by the needs assessment instrument

*      The capabilities of the Emotional Support Brigade could be enhanced with training in simple counseling skills (e.g. with use of WHO manuals).

*      Training of physicians in the islands to deliver mental health services for the Tsunami- affected communities.

*      Community health workers could be trained in the identification and management of common psychiatric conditions using the same material as for physicians.

b)     Recommendations for implementation of the needs assessment instrument

*      Needs assessment to assess the magnitude of psychosocial distress should be conducted for all adults in the affected islands. MOH may consider conducting the same needs assessment for families indirectly affected due to large numbers of displaced persons moving into the their households.

*      MOH may consider if data management support for needs assessment instrument can be provided by the expert already placed in the MOH for 3 months.

c)     Recruitment of a mental health consultant and a mental health professional

*      A consultant in mental health may be immediately recruited. His/her main assignment will be training of physicians and paramedical staff. A draft TOR which was discussed with MOH is attached. (Annex 2)

*      A mental health profession could be recruited to work in the MOH to assist in development of mental health policy and services. A draft TOR which was discussed with MOH is attached. (Annex 2)

d)     Training

*      Inthe short-term the consultant in mental health to be recruited will do the training of physicians and paramedical staff. In the long-term the Faculty of Health Sciences (FHS) will train the paramedical staff.

*      A staff member of the FHS should be sent to observe curricula for paramedical staff (nurses, community health workers) being implemented in some other centre.


e)     e) Recommendations for the programme on epilepsy

        i.     Training of all paramedical staff (nurses, community health workers, family health workers) at the RegionalHospital, AtollHospital and health posts

Master trainers in the northern and southern region have been trained for the identification and management of generalized tonic clonic seizures. Master trainers in the central region need to be trained.  These master trainers can train other paramedical staff on identification and care of patients with generalized tonic clonic seizures  with the technical material provided by WHO.  Nurses and family health workers and  can be trained in the identification and care of generalzed tonic clonic seizures, while community health workers if they are allowed to prescribe anti-epileptic drugs can be trained in the management of generalized tonic clonic seizures.

      ii.      All physicians at the Regional Hospital/Atoll Hospital/Health posts should be provided the technical material developed by WHO on the identification and management of generalized tonic clonic seizures.

      iii.       Community education through Information, Education and Communication (IEC) campaigns. WHO has developed a video on stigma removal which has a dual sound track and could be dubbed in Dvivehi. Local experts could develop IEC material (posters, pamphlets, messages on the radio etc) on epilepsy to inform the people about epilepsy and encourage people to seek treatment.

     iv.      Ensuring availability of phenobarbital. The continuous availability of phenobarbital should be ensured at the Regional Hosptial/Atoll Hospital/Health Centre/Health Posts and an additional drug (eg. phenytoin sodium) for patients who do not respond to phenobarbital, should be made available at the Regional and AtollHospital.

      v.      Regular reporting and monitoring of the programme at the Regional level

The quarterly reporting of identified cases, treatment started, and control of seizures should be done and data should be sent regularly to the Regional level. A draft of the forms that can be used are attached in Annex 3.

     vi.      Establish a referral system for hard to treat cases. Those patients that do not respond to treatment at the Atoll Hosptial should be referred to the Regional Hospital/IGMH Hospital in Male for care under experts.

    vii.       Population-based interventions: Public health policies that can modify risk factors for epilepsy will help reduce the incidence and prevalence of epilepsy. Examples of such policies include improving the quality of obstetric services through well trained birth attendants.  Strengthening of Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses especially for fever and infections. Campaigns to educate communities about the medical nature of epilepsy and remove myths and misconceptions about epilepsy could reduce stigma against epilepsy and encourage patients to seek medical treatment.
 

 

 

| | | | | |